Pony's

Pony's, located at 23 Main St Middleport, NY 14105, offers a cozy and welcoming atmosphere perfect for casual dining. This charming restaurant is known for its delicious comfort food, friendly service, and unique features that make it stand out in the area. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Pony's offers something for everyone, from hearty burgers to mouth-watering wings. Here's a closer look at what makes Pony's a go-to spot for a satisfying meal.

A Menu Full of Flavorful Comfort Food

Pony's serves a menu filled with classic American comfort food favorites. Their signature items include a variety of burgers, from the simple Hamburger W/ Fries to the indulgent Double Cheeseburger W/ Fries. For those craving something crispy, the Fried Chicken Sandwich W/ Fries is a popular choice. If you're in the mood for some tasty starters, Pony's Huge Boneless Wings are a must-try, alongside options like Pickle Chips W/ Ranch or Boom Boom, and Buffalo Chicken Wing Dip served with chips.

The menu also includes a few crowd-pleasers, such as Pretzel Sticks, Battered Mushrooms, and a selection of combo specials. Each dish is designed to satisfy a wide range of cravings, from light bites to hearty meals that leave you feeling full and content.

The Unique Dining Experience at Pony's

Pony's isn't just about great food—it offers a unique experience that keeps customers coming back. The restaurant’s relaxed, casual atmosphere makes it perfect for groups, while the variety of services ensures everyone feels comfortable. Whether you're dining indoors or outdoors, the space is wheelchair accessible, and there's even a heated outdoor seating option for colder weather. With a full bar, juke box, and TV, Pony's creates a fun, vibrant environment where you can enjoy your meal and hang out with friends or family.

For those who appreciate a laid-back dining experience, Pony's offers free Wi-Fi, a pool table, and even bike parking for those who prefer cycling. The restaurant’s casual setting is complemented by moderate noise levels, ensuring a comfortable dining experience for groups of all sizes. Plus, the option to make reservations and the easy access to street and on-site parking adds extra convenience for diners.

What Customers Are Saying About Pony's

Customer feedback highlights the welcoming nature of Pony's, as well as the consistently delicious food. Dave V. shared that he and his wife enjoyed a Cheeseburger and wings, noting how great the food tasted and how clean the business was. He also appreciated the friendly staff and the easy access for anyone with mobility issues. Similarly, Diana W. took her family to Pony’s on Father's Day and praised the chicken fingers and family bundle, which provided more than enough food for three people. She also mentioned the welcoming bartender/waitress who made the visit memorable.

Madison L. also gave a glowing review, highlighting the flavorful food, the impressive remodel of the restaurant, and the friendly and prompt service from the staff. These reviews underscore Pony's commitment to providing great food and an enjoyable experience for all who visit.

Pony's continues to be a standout choice for anyone looking for a comfortable, casual dining spot that combines delicious food with a lively atmosphere. Whether you're enjoying a meal with friends, having a family dinner, or simply stopping by for a bite, Pony's offers a place where good times and great food go hand in hand.