Pony's
  • Photos
  • Menu
  • Location
  • Work Hours
  • Business info
  • Reviews

Pony's Menu

Menu Pony's-1
Menu Pony's-1
Menu Pony's-2
Menu Pony's-2

Entrees

Hamburger W/ Fries
$14.00
Double Hamburger W/ Fries
$17.00
Cheeseburger W/ Fries
$14.50
Double Cheeseburger W/ Fries
$17.50
Fried Chicken Sandwich W/ Fries
$14.00
Chicken Finger Wrap W/ Fries
$13.00
Fish Fry W/ Fries & Salad
$18.00
Pony's Garbage Platter
$18.00

Sides & Starters

Pony's Huge Boneless Wings
$14.00
Pickle Chips W/ Ranch Or Boom Boom
$9.00
Buffalo Chicken Wing Dip W/Chips
$9.00
Pretzel Sticks
$9.00
Battered Mushrooms
$9.00
Jalapeno Poppers
$9.00
Mozzarella Sticks
$9.00
Side Salad
$6.00
Onion Petals
$9.00
Pizza Logs
$8.00
French Fries
$7.00
Loaded Fries W/ Bacon & Cheese
$10.00
Funnel Cake Fries
$9.00
Apple Pie Logs W/ Icing
$9.00
Cheeseburger Silders
$6.00
Kettle Chips
$2.50

Combo Specials

Hamburger W/ Fries
Double Hamburger W/ Fries
Cheeseburger W/ Fries
Double Cheeseburger W/ Fries
Fried Chicken Sandwich W/ Fries
Fried Shrimp W/ Fries
Chicken Finger Wrap W/ Fries
Pony's Boneless Wings
Fish Fry W/ Homemade Chips Or Fries
Pony's Garbage Platter
Soup Of The Day

Others

Fingers
$18.50

If you’re craving comfort food with a touch of indulgence, Pony's menu is a treasure trove of classic delights, perfect for any craving. Let's dive into some of the standout dishes that will make your taste buds sing.

For those who appreciate a hearty, satisfying meal, the Hamburger with Fries is a no-brainer. It’s a perfectly seasoned patty, juicy and tender, paired with crispy, golden fries that complement the burger’s richness. If you're looking for a bit more indulgence, the Double Hamburger with Fries takes it up a notch with two patties stacked high for double the flavor. But if you’re a cheese lover, don’t miss the Cheeseburger with Fries, where the melted cheese adds a creamy richness to the juicy patty. For the ultimate indulgence, the Double Cheeseburger with Fries combines the best of both worlds, delivering a satisfying and decadent bite in every mouthful. And for those in the mood for something crispy, the Fried Chicken Sandwich with Fries is an absolute must-try, with a perfectly seasoned and fried chicken fillet tucked between a soft bun, paired with fries that are simply irresistible.

If you're in the mood for some lighter bites or starters, Pony's offers an array of delicious sides. The Pony's Huge Boneless Wings are a perfect choice, featuring tender, juicy chicken covered in your choice of sauce. Pair them with Pickle Chips with Ranch or Boom Boom Sauce, a tangy, crunchy delight that’s both refreshing and indulgent. The Buffalo Chicken Wing Dip with Chips brings together the smoky, spicy flavors of buffalo chicken in a creamy dip, served with crispy chips for the perfect combo. Other tempting options like Pretzel Sticks, Battered Mushrooms, and crispy Fingers round out the menu, ensuring there's something for everyone to enjoy.

Pony's menu is a celebration of comfort food done right—generous portions, rich flavors, and that undeniable satisfaction with every bite.

Pony's

Pony's - An Irish Pub located at 23 Main St Middleport, NY 14105 offering a variety of entrees such as burgers, sandwiches, and the famous Pony's Garbage Platter. Enjoy sides like boneless wings and starters like jalapeno poppers. Don't miss out on combo specials and the friendly atmosphere. Customer reviews praise the great food and welcoming staff. Wheelchair accessible and free Wi-Fi available. Contact (716) 735-9989 for reservations.

Follow Us
  • Yelp
  • tripadvisor
Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.